Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Blake, Hughes and Kees Poetry Response
All three of the poems incorporate somebody's child. Langston Hughes " Mother to Son" is narrating a woman telling her son that her life wasn't a "crystal stair" (Hughes 1018), which i interpret to mean beautiful and rich. She tells him that life has been a struggle for her. She says, " It's had tacks in it, and splinters, and boards torn up" (Hughes 1018) meaning that her life had flaws, pain and obstacles. She doesn't give up and she keeps on "climbing" ( Hughes 1019) her stair of life and she wants her son to do the same. No matter what to keep on going and never stop. For the child in William Blake's "The Chimney Sweeper" the mother is not alive. After she passes away his father put him to work as a Chimney Sweeper and one of his friend dreams of all of the chimney sweepers being " locked up in coffins of black" ( Blake 706) which I believe translates to trapped and the coffin which connects to death means their lives are a standstill. But an angel comes and says ,"' if he'd be a good boy, He'd have God for his father, and never want joy." I believe this gives the dreamer Tom and the rest of the chimney sweepers hope that things will be better, all they have to do is be good and go on with their duties. A reoccurring theme i saw in both Hughes and Blake's poem was hope, hope for the children. Weldon Kees poem " For my Daughter" is kind of a dark poem, he talks about his daughter having to go through troubles in her life and he knows that it is inevitable. At the end of the poem, " I have no daughter. I desire none" can give me or the reader hope ( reoccurring theme) that he actually has no daughter and desires not to have one because of all the troubles and darkness she would have to face that he would not be able to protect her from. So both hope and children are themes that pop up in all three of the poems.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
i think we both saw the three stories from the same perspective. In "Mother to Son" from Langston Hughes. In my interpretation the mother is trying to tell her son that not everything that glitters is gold. In life he will face many obstacles and when you see yourself in the bottom that's not the time to give up. For example she tells him "So boy, don't you turn back. Don't you set down on the steps 'Cause you finds it's kinder hard.". in the other poem "The Chimney Sweeper" there's hope, overcome in life and move forward.
ReplyDeleteKaren- great post! Thank you. To connect your comments regarding the "crystal stair" in Hughes' poem as beautiful and rich, to Cristal's comment that all that glitters is not gold, ultimately it seems that the mother is warning her son, teaching him about life. But why does the mother say that the "crystal stair" has been full of "tacks...splinters" (Hughes 2, 3-4)? Why not stick to the image of "crystal" and say that is has been slippery or covered is shards of glass?
ReplyDeleteAlso, Karen, think about whether Blake's poem is hopeful or in fact as dark as Kees? When will the chimney sweepers see their father, God?